Ice Cream
Our small-batch, handcrafted ice cream is made weekly at Milking R Dairy using fresh milk from our own cows and locally sourced, high-quality ingredients. What began as a farm favorite is now a South Florida sensation!
You can find our ice cream right here at the farm in Okeechobee. Or you can visit stores across the west side of Lake Okeechobee, in select markets from West Palm Beach to Miami and select farm stores in Osceola County. Be sure to check our locator to find your closest store.
As a family-run operation, our hours reflect time reserved for both family and high quality ice cream production. We're closed Monday through Wednesday to focus on crafting the ice cream everyone’s talking about—so it’s always fresh when you stop by.
Visit us at the farm
Thursday: 2–6 PM
Friday: 11–6 PM
Saturday: 11–4 PM
Sunday: 1–4 PM
handcrafted and homemade
High Quality Ingredients
We take pride in sourcing the highest quality ingredients for our ice cream. We don’t skimp on cost to provide the best ice cream possible. This is why our ice cream tastes so decadent.
Handcrafted and Homemade
All of our ice cream is made right here on the farm in small batches to ensure we are keeping our high standard of quality.
Delicious, Unique Flavors
We offer over 40 unique flavors a week to pick from. Our flavors rotate weekly and can include Banana Puddin’, Cookie Butter, Strawberry Cheesecake Crunch, Cow Tracks, Dirt Road Delight and many other classic flavors. You are sure to find one to satisfy your sweet tooth.
Creamy
Our ice cream speaks for itself. The creamiest farm fresh ice cream you will find. Once you taste our ice cream you will keep coming back for more.
More Than Just Ice Cream
At Sutton Milk, we’ve created more than a place to pick up ice cream—we’ve built a destination where families can relax, play, and make memories together. While our handcrafted ice cream is sold in pre-packaged containers, the real treat is the time you’ll spend enjoying the farm.
Let the kids run free, play mini golf, race on our duck races, or take turns on the tire swings and seesaws. We have basketball hoops, a play ice cream stand for pretend scooping fun, and plenty of shaded spots to unwind. Families love meeting our retired show cows and feeding our mischievous escape-artist goats—always a hit with the little ones!
Whether you’re local or just passing through, Sutton Milk is a place to slow down, laugh out loud, and create memories that last long after the ice cream is gone.
Get your sweet treat on the farm
